Menachem Mendel

Menachem Mendel RSS Feed
 
 
 
 

More on Rav Ovadiah and Women Reading Megillah

There has been lots of discussion about Rav Ovadiah’s statement regarding women reading Megillat Esther for men. See my previous post here, this post at Hirhurim, and this post at My Obiter Dicta. I just had a chance to look over the relevant sections in Hazon Ovadiah on Purim (Thanks go out to my friend Mordechai S. for keeping me updated on Rav Ovadiah’s books and going with me to buy them this past December in Israel.) and he writes the following on p. 60 in the note.

“ודע שביישוב קטן שאין שם איש שיודע לקרוא את המגילה כהלכה, ויש שם אשה שיודעת לקרות המגילה, בואדי שיכולה לקרוא להם המגילה בטעמיה, וליכא למיחש למידי.”

And know that in a small settlement where there is no man who knows how to read the megillah properly, and there is a woman that knows how to read the megillah, of course she is able to read the megillah with its cantillations for them, and there is no reason to doubt this.

Hazon Ovadiah on Purim was published in 2003 and I now take back having said that he was never explicit about this as a practical alternative before.

Update: See this nice overview of the question by R. Eliezer Melamed (Hebrew). This is from last year and he refers to the above quoted source from Hazon Ovadiah.

One Response to “More on Rav Ovadiah and Women Reading Megillah”

  1. 1
    מ:

    Rav Ovadiah’s approach on this question is not new. One can already find it in Yalkut Yoseph 5 Hagim p. 287-8 (תשמח)The hiddush that I have not found before in his writings concerns a woman writing a megillah.

Categories

Tags

Archives

Recent Posts

Meta

Sign up for an email subscribtion to this blog.

Michael Pitkowsky

Biblioblogs

Daf Yomi

History

Israel

Jewish Law

Judaica

Law and Legal History

Politics

Religion

Talmud