Menachem Mendel

Menachem Mendel

Menachem Mendel RSS Feed

R. Ovadia Yosef

Last week I received two new books relating to R. Ovadia Yosef. The first is Benny Lau’s book ממרן עד מרן (“From ‘Our Teacher’ to ‘Our Teacher'”-The first “Our Teacher” being Yosef Karo, and the second R. Ovadia) which was mentionned here by Manuscriptboy. While I haven’t read much of the book, adapted from Lau’s Ph.D. dissertation, it seems like a thorough examination of R. Ovadia’s “halakhic philosophy.” While most of the public in Israel and abroad knows R. Ovadia from either his occasional outrageous statements that he makes in his weekly lectures (see here at Wikipedia for some examples) or his political affiliation with the political party Shas, I have no hesitation in saying that he is one of the most important figures in halakhah since Yosef Karo, hence I agree with Lau’s title.

The second book which I received also relates to R. Ovadia but discusses a far more controversial side of his activities which Lau touches upon in his book, yet is unknown to most of the Jewish world including most people in Israel (Towards the end of his review of Lau’s book, Shlomo Deshen mentions it). One of the pillars of R. Ovadia’s halakhic philosophy is that all Jews whose origins are in North Africa or the Middle East, commonly known as Sephardic or Oriental Jews, must hold by the teachings of Maran, Yosef Karo. One of the results of this is what I call Pax Ovadia, meaning that R. Ovadia is attempting to have all Sephardic Jews only observe Jewish laws and customs that in his eyes are loyal to the teachings of Yosef Karo. As the influence of R. Ovadia increased and later also that of his sons, the displeasure with this attempt at uniformity among Sephardic Jews caused great unease among many rabbis, some from the Iraqi community and others from Morocco or other North African countries. A number of years ago R. Shelomo Toledano published a book called ספר דברי שלום ואמת whose stated purpose was to “Strengthen some laws in the spirit of the decision-making of North African sages, from Morocco to Libya, against the undermining of them in the Holy Land.” The Rashi: he is trying to defend Sephardic customs, primarily those from Morocco, which R. Ovadia has come out against. He analyzes numerous customs and usually tries to show that the Moroccan tradition is either the authentic tradition of Yosef Karo or that it is a very old tradition which Yosef Karo did not necessarily intend to supersede (see the intro. to his Beit Yosef). Toledano is very learned and clearly has a historical perspective of the development of customs and of traditions, often referring to scientific (for lack of a better word) literature on the subject to illustrate his point. He also includes a number of programatic essays regarding the authority of Yosef Karo, the place of pluralism in Jewish law, etc. Well I just got the second volume and it is even more interesting than the first.

For those in America who are interested in the books of R. Ovadia the best place to get them is iSefer or you can probably find at least his responsa at the YU Seforim Sale. iSefer has almost all of his books, including many of his lesser known ones.

3 Responses to “R. Ovadia Yosef”

  1. 1
    R. Ovadiah Yosef on Customs:

    […] have written before about R. Ovadiah Yosef’s attitude towards different customs, and this recently published book […]

  2. 2
    The Customs of the Land of Israel and R. Yosef Karo « Menachem Mendel:

    […] the מרא דאתרא, the local authority, in the Land of Israel. See a previous post about them here. He has recently published an article in the journal מים מדליו (no. 18) on Minhagei Eretz […]

  3. 3
    Menachem Mendel:

    Doesn’t R. Ovadiah even extend his ideology to not only all Sefardim, but to all Ashkenazim that live in Israel. He claims that since one is obligated to follow minhag haMokom and Sefardim were there first, everyone needs to follow them.
    Dan Rabinowitz | Homepage | 01.27.06 – 8:30 am | #

    I don’t think that R. Ovadia feels that Ashkenazim have to accept the authority of Karo, neither does Lau, since it was Sephardim who in the past accepted his authority but for numerous reasons haven’t been able to live up to that acceptance.
    Menachem Mendel | Homepage | 01.27.06 – 8:56 am | #

    I don’t know about Rav Ovadia himself, but what Dan says is what Rav Ovadia’s grandson said to me once, when we were in high school together.
    manuscriptboy | Homepage | 01.30.06 – 10:16 pm | #

    It could be that Lau is trying to play down Rav Ovadia’s intentions towards Ashkenazim and/or I am recalling an incorrect impression from his writings. I’ll have to keep this question in mind when I read something of his in the future.
    Menachem Mendel | Homepage | 01.30.06 – 11:38 pm | #

    he may hold that but he still poskens for “acheinu benei Askenaz”
    so don’t yearn ro hard for matzah ashira on Pesach yet,
    m | 01.31.06 – 10:40 am | #

    Re Moroccan minhogim – I heard R. Bonyomin Hamburger (of Shorshei Minhag Ashkenaz) say that Rabbeinu Asher (the Rosh) brought some Ashkenazic practices with him when he moved to Spain and some of those survived, and migrated to Morocco.

    Are some of those involved in the R. Ovadia – Moroccan conflict or is it just other stuff ?
    anonymous | 02.08.06 – 4:03 am | #

    I have to go throught he two volumes and see what are the origins of the halakhot and minhagim which are contending and see if any can be traced back to the Rosh.
    Menachem Mendel | Homepage | 02.09.06 – 9:48 pm | #




Recent Posts


Sign up for an email subscribtion to this blog.

Michael Pitkowsky


Daf Yomi



Jewish Law


Law and Legal History