Menachem Mendel

Menachem Mendel

Menachem Mendel RSS Feed

Toward Critical Halakhic Studies

Recommended reading:

Adiel Schremer’s working paper, Toward Critical Halakhic Studies. Here is the abstract:

Current scholarly study of Jewish law concentrates either on a description and analysis of halakhic doctrines, or on the jurisprudential theories underlying the thought of halakhic thinkers. Questions such as: “how halakhic decisions are actually produced?”, and “what are the various constraints operating in halakhic decision-making?”, usually receive very limited attention in the study of Halakha. This paper calls for a shift of focus, from the “theoretical” (whether doctrinal or philosophical) to the “practical”, so that the halakhic process will occupy a central role in the study of Jewish law.

The emphasis on the need to study the halakhic process was also stated by Marc B. Shapiro in idem, Review: “Jewish Obligation and the Modern World: Rabbi Hayyim Hirschenson and His Approach to Modernity” by David Zohar,” Edah 5,1 (2005). (here)

By way of criticism, or better, suggestions for future researchers, let me note that while Zohar’s book is certainly where all future analysis of Hirschensohn’s halakhic thought will begin, there still remains a good deal that Zohar has not examined. Zohar’s interest is primarily in Hirschensohn’s conclusions, but the process whereby Hirschensohn reached his conclusions is also fascinating. The way Hirschensohn is able to work within the halakhic process and his most original method of halakhic argumentation still remain to be analyzed in a comprehensive fashion.

2 Responses to “Toward Critical Halakhic Studies”

  1. 1
    Harry Perkal:

    If I had one wish it is that the notion of Jewish or religious law be eliminated from JUdaism- or at least non-Orthodox Judaism. It makes no sense in a modern , democrtaic world. Do we really want to live in a theocracy. Why not talk about religious traditions, rituals, etc instead of legal terminology. Religious practice grows organically from a community, and not from pseudo leaglistic rabbinic rulings. Harry

  2. 2

    Dani Statman made a related proposal, and some other professors responded to it in a recent issue of the Textual Reasoning journal:




Recent Posts


Sign up for an email subscribtion to this blog.

Michael Pitkowsky


Daf Yomi



Jewish Law


Law and Legal History